US states that have elected someone who was already dead

In the US a candidate who dies close to an election often stays on the ballot, and in these ten states one has gone on to win.

Map of the US with Missouri, Hawaii, Nevada, North Dakota, Pennsylvania, Texas, Tennessee, Washington, California and Georgia in black as states that have elected someone who was already dead
How terrible is this map?
1 = honestly fine10 = truly terrible

The Senate race a dead man won

Mel Carnahan, the governor of Missouri, was running for the Senate in 2000 against the sitting senator, John Ashcroft, when he died, three weeks before the vote. It was too late to change the ballot under Missouri law, so his name stayed on it.

Missouri’s new governor promised that if Carnahan won, he would appoint Carnahan’s widow, Jean, to the seat. Carnahan won by 50.46% to 48.39%, and Jean became the first woman to represent Missouri in the Senate.

Ashcroft is still the only senator ever beaten for re-election by someone who had died. He conceded with “I hope the outcome of this election is a comfort to Mrs. Carnahan”, and by February he had a new job anyway, as the US Attorney General. Jean Carnahan, by then a senator, voted against him.

Dead members of Congress

The House of Representatives’ own historian keeps a list of members elected after they died, and the oldest case is from 1836. John Coffee of Georgia died in September and was re-elected in October, because news of his death hadn’t reached the voters.

Patsy Mink of Hawaii died in September 2002, a week after winning her primary. It was too late to take her name off the ballot, and she was re-elected with 56%. Filling her seat then took two special elections, one for the rest of her old term and one for the new one, with about 38 and then about 44 candidates.

Two more men were re-elected in 1972 but aren’t on the map. Nick Begich of Alaska and Hale Boggs of Louisiana were on a plane that went missing before the election, and they weren’t declared dead until afterwards, so their states stay light blue.

State legislatures

In Nevada, Dennis Hof, who ran legal brothels and called himself the Trump from Pahrump, beat the sitting assemblyman in the primary and then died in October 2018. He won the seat in November with 63%, and his supporters announced that he was henceforth to be referred to as Assemblyman Dennis Hof.

Tony DeLuca, Pennsylvania’s longest-serving state representative, died in October 2022 and was re-elected a month later with about 86% of the vote. A Democrat, Joe McAndrew, won the special election for his seat, and with two other Democratic wins the same day that gave the party a one-seat majority in the Pennsylvania House, its first in about a decade.

In North Dakota, David Andahl beat Jeff Delzer, who had held the seat since 1995, in the 2020 Republican primary for the state House. Andahl then died a month before the general election and won it anyway. The governor appointed a coal executive to the seat, the local party picked Delzer, and the state Supreme Court ruled that the governor had no power to appoint anyone. So Delzer, the man the voters had just turned down, got the seat after all.

In Texas, state senator Mario Gallegos Jr. died too close to the 2012 election for his name to come off the ballot, and won by more than 55,000 votes. California, Washington and Tennessee have similar cases, all in the table below.

StateWhoElected to
MissouriMel CarnahanUS Senate, 2000
GeorgiaJohn CoffeeUS House, 1836
NevadaDennis HofState Assembly, 2018
North DakotaDavid AndahlState House, 2020
HawaiiPatsy MinkUS House, 2002
See all 10 states
CaliforniaClem Miller and Jenny OropezaUS House, 1962, and State Senate, 2010
TexasMario Gallegos Jr.State Senate, 2012
WashingtonRoger FreemanState House, 2014
TennesseeBarbara CooperState House, 2022
PennsylvaniaTony DeLucaState House, 2022

If you like this sort of thing, see the US towns with an animal for mayor or the countries where you can legally marry a dead person.

Sources: Wikipedia, 2000 Senate election in Missouri, Mel Carnahan, Jean Carnahan, John Ashcroft; CBS News, Ashcroft concedes; US House history, election firsts, Patsy Mink; Wikipedia, Clem Miller, Nick Begich, Hale Boggs, Dennis Hof; KTNV, 2018; Wikipedia, Mario Gallegos Jr., Jenny Oropeza; The Week, Roger Freeman; Wikipedia, Barbara Cooper, Tony DeLuca, David Andahl; Ballotpedia, 2021; Pennsylvania Capital-Star, 2023; AP, 2020.

Random map →

Leave a comment