Lake Champlain was a Great Lake for 18 days

For 18 days in 1998, Lake Champlain was officially the sixth Great Lake, until the states around the real five made Congress take it back.

Map of the Great Lakes in blue with Lake Champlain, between New York and Vermont, in red, labelled a Great Lake for 18 days in 1998
How terrible is this map?
1 = honestly fine10 = truly terrible

How Lake Champlain became a Great Lake

Lake Champlain lies mostly between New York and Vermont, with its northern tip in Quebec. In 1998 Vermont’s senator, Patrick Leahy, added one line to a bill renewing the National Sea Grant College Program: “The term ‘Great Lakes’ includes Lake Champlain.” It went through as part of a batch of what Michigan’s senator Spencer Abraham later called “technical issues”, and nobody noticed.

Leahy did it for research money. Sea Grant is a federal programme worth roughly $50 million a year, according to the magazine Government Executive, and Vermont’s colleges could only get its Great Lakes money by teaming up with schools in Great Lakes states. If Champlain was a Great Lake, they could apply for it themselves. President Clinton signed the bill, Lake Champlain line and all, on 6 March 1998.

Why Michigan objected

Lake Champlain covers about 514 square miles. Lake Ontario, the smallest of the real Great Lakes, covers about 7,340, so about 14 Champlains would fit inside it. Fred Upton, a congressman from Michigan, put it simply: “Lake Champlain may be a big lake, but it’s no Great Lake.”

On the Senate floor, Michigan’s Carl Levin pointed out that American children learn the five Great Lakes with the word HOMES, one letter for each lake, and called the whole thing a matter of the region’s “very identity”. Abraham said he couldn’t think of a new word with Champlain in it that children would still be able to remember.

How it was taken back after 18 days

Leahy agreed to take the line out, as long as Vermont kept its access to the money. On 24 March 1998, 18 days after the bill was signed, the Senate passed his amendment without objection. Strictly the line stayed in the law until the fix was signed that May, but everyone had already agreed it was over. Vermont’s colleges could still apply in the same way as a school in a Great Lakes state.

Leahy said Lake Champlain would be “the cousin instead of a little brother” to the big lakes. He also said the purpose of his amendment “was not to change any maps”, which held until I made this one.

If you like this sort of thing, see why Virginia is further west than West Virginia or countries that couldn’t think of a name for their capital.

Sources: Public Law 105-160 (1998), Public Law 105-174, Sec. 10003; Congressional Record, Senate, 24 March 1998; Government Executive, February 1998; Spokesman-Review, 25 March 1998; Lake Champlain Sea Grant; Wikipedia, Lake Champlain, Lake Ontario.

Random map →

Leave a comment