Where the pumpkins for pumpkin pie are grown

Illinois has 86% of the land America uses to grow pumpkins for tins, so on this map it gets the big pie and the rest of the country gets the small one.

Illinois drawn as a giant pumpkin pie labelled 86%, next to a small pie of the rest of the United States labelled everyone else 14%
How terrible is this map?
1 = honestly fine10 = truly terrible

More Thanksgiving maps→

Which state grows the most pumpkins?

Illinois grows the most pumpkins of any state, about 533 million pounds in 2025, which was more than a third of the whole US crop and over three times as much as California in second place.

The map’s 86% only counts pumpkins grown for tins, which take up about 15% of America’s pumpkin fields, because the rest grow the ones people buy fresh to carve or decorate.

Illinois also grows the most for the size of its population, with about 1.5 acres of pumpkins for every 1,000 people against 1 acre in Indiana, as the second map shows.

Map of the US showing acres of pumpkins grown per 1,000 people in each state, with Illinois highest at 1.5 and Indiana next at 1
Acres of pumpkins of every kind for every 1,000 people. Sources: USDA 2022 Census of Agriculture and US Census Bureau 2024 population estimates.

Indiana’s pumpkins were worth more than Illinois’s in 2025, $32 million, because most of Illinois’s pumpkin fields grow pumpkins for tins, and those sell for much less per pound than the ones people buy to carve.

Illinois grew nearly four times as many pumpkins as Indiana and made less money, so the most profitable thing to do with a pumpkin is not eat it.

The Pumpkin Capital of the World

About 90% of the canned pumpkin made in the US is grown within 60 miles of Morton, a village near Peoria in Illinois.

Morton has a cannery owned by Libby’s, the biggest canned pumpkin brand in the country, and pumpkins have been canned there since the 1920s. Libby’s itself now belongs to Nestlé.

Pumpkins are heavy and expensive to move, so the farms that grow them for Libby’s are close to the cannery. Libby’s buys each year’s crop in December, months before it’s planted.

Morton calls itself the Pumpkin Capital of the World, which on these numbers seems fair.

Is canned pumpkin really pumpkin?

In Libby’s case it is, though not the kind you’d carve. Libby’s uses a variety called the Dickinson, a tall, oblong, pale tan pumpkin with a rind like a butternut squash’s, and carving pumpkins belong to a different species altogether.

Libby’s says its tins are 100% pumpkin, and I found nothing to show they hold anything other than Dickinsons.

Other tins might not, because since 1969 the US Food and Drug Administration has said it will accept the word pumpkin on tins made from golden-fleshed, sweet squash, so the label alone can’t tell you which you’ve got.

When it rains on Morton

With so much of America’s canned pumpkin grown around one village, one wet summer there can hit the whole country’s supply.

June 2015 was the wettest June on record in Illinois, with 11.1 inches of rain in Morton, about 28 centimetres, and Nestlé said its yields were down by half.

It had happened before, in 2009, when the fields were so wet that pumpkins were left to spoil in the mud. Nestlé stopped picking for the rest of the season, and canned pumpkin was in short supply that Thanksgiving.

StateAll pumpkins, 2022 (acres)For tins, 2022 (acres)
Illinois18,77712,870
Indiana7,01710
Texas6,353154
Pennsylvania5,770163
California4,934None
See all 50 states
Michigan4,858Not published
New York4,577144
Ohio4,28659
Virginia4,02859
North Carolina3,939452
Wisconsin3,108None
Washington3,02958
Colorado3,0288
Oregon2,843Not published
Minnesota2,0181
New Jersey1,98445
New Mexico1,5881
Massachusetts1,52915
Arkansas1,410Not published
Missouri1,36012
Kentucky1,30180
Tennessee1,032Not published
Utah1,00414
Connecticut9452
Nebraska8729
Iowa793None
Kansas781Not published
Maryland755Not published
Delaware726Not published
Maine6399
Vermont57022
Oklahoma5081
Alabama481None
New Hampshire35610
Idaho29416
South Carolina257None
Hawaii246None
West Virginia24412
Mississippi21415
South Dakota1743
Montana1641
Georgia144None
Rhode Island120Not published
Nevada98None
Florida73None
Louisiana591
Arizona561
North Dakota531
Wyoming15None
Alaska51

If you like this sort of thing, see where each country thinks the turkey is from or the rest of my Thanksgiving maps.

Sources: USDA 2022 Census of Agriculture (pumpkins, acres harvested; processing pumpkins: Illinois 12,870 of 14,969 acres); USDA Economic Research Service; University of Illinois Extension; Chicago Sun-Times via WBEZ, October 2026; St. Louis Public Radio, November 2024; High Plains Public Radio, 2013; Wikipedia, Dickinson pumpkin, Morton Pumpkin Festival; FDA, pumpkin labelling; Tasting Table; Omni Calculator; Associated Press, 2009; Illinois State Climatologist, 2015; Food Dive, 2015.

Random map →

Leave a comment