Each state’s most hated Thanksgiving dish

In 2019 a food website counted more than 50,000 angry tweets about Thanksgiving dishes, each with a location, to see which dish people in each state complained about most. In Maine, Oregon and Idaho it was the turkey.

Map of the US on a dinner plate showing each state's most hated Thanksgiving dish: cranberry sauce in 17 states, green bean casserole in 12, stuffing in 9, sweet potatoes in 6, pumpkin pie in Louisiana, Virginia and Pennsylvania, and turkey in Maine, Oregon and Idaho
How terrible is this map?
1 = honestly fine10 = truly terrible

More Thanksgiving maps→

What is the most hated Thanksgiving food?

In most national surveys, cranberry sauce is the Thanksgiving food people like least, and on this map it comes out top in 17 states.

Green bean casserole is second with 12 states, ahead of stuffing on 9 and sweet potatoes on 6. Pumpkin pie was the most complained-about dish in only three states, Louisiana, Virginia and Pennsylvania.

The Daring Kitchen counted tweets from 1 November 2019 that said things like “I hate turkey” or “I hate cranberry sauce”, covering six dishes. The map shows which of the six each state complained about most.

In a 2023 poll by the Associated Press and NORC, 18% of Americans named cranberry sauce as the part of the Thanksgiving meal they liked least, more than any other dish.

People buy it anyway. Customers of the grocery delivery service Instacart bought 50% more canned cranberry sauce than fresh cranberries at Thanksgiving 2018, and in Instacart’s 2019 poll 68% of Americans said they eat dishes they don’t like because of tradition.

The three states where it was the turkey

In Maine, Oregon and Idaho, more tweets complained about the turkey than about any other dish. I couldn’t find anyone who has explained why.

In the 2023 AP-NORC poll, 12% named turkey as the part of the meal they liked least, while 32% named it the best part.

Where green bean casserole came from

Green bean casserole, the most complained-about dish in 12 states, was invented in 1955 by Dorcas Reilly, a 29-year-old cook in the test kitchen of the soup company Campbell’s, in New Jersey.

She made it for an Associated Press feature article that needed a quick dish from ordinary cupboard ingredients, one of which was a can of Campbell’s cream of mushroom soup.

The recipe still has only six ingredients. In 2020 Campbell’s estimated that it was served at about 20 million Thanksgiving dinners a year.

How much to trust this map

Treat it as a count of angry tweets, not a survey.

Fewer than 1 in 100 tweets carry a location, and a study of the people who add one found they aren’t typical of Twitter users. I couldn’t find how many tweets came from each state, either.

StateMost hated dish
IdahoTurkey
MaineTurkey
OregonTurkey
LouisianaPumpkin pie
PennsylvaniaPumpkin pie
See all 50 states
VirginiaPumpkin pie
AlabamaStuffing
AlaskaGreen bean casserole
ArizonaStuffing
ArkansasStuffing
CaliforniaCranberry sauce
ColoradoGreen bean casserole
ConnecticutCranberry sauce
DelawareSweet potatoes
FloridaCranberry sauce
GeorgiaCranberry sauce
HawaiiStuffing
IllinoisGreen bean casserole
IndianaCranberry sauce
IowaGreen bean casserole
KansasGreen bean casserole
KentuckyGreen bean casserole
MarylandCranberry sauce
MassachusettsCranberry sauce
MichiganCranberry sauce
MinnesotaGreen bean casserole
MississippiStuffing
MissouriGreen bean casserole
MontanaStuffing
NebraskaCranberry sauce
NevadaSweet potatoes
New HampshireCranberry sauce
New JerseyCranberry sauce
New MexicoSweet potatoes
New YorkCranberry sauce
North CarolinaStuffing
North DakotaSweet potatoes
OhioGreen bean casserole
OklahomaGreen bean casserole
Rhode IslandCranberry sauce
South CarolinaStuffing
South DakotaSweet potatoes
TennesseeStuffing
TexasCranberry sauce
UtahGreen bean casserole
VermontCranberry sauce
WashingtonCranberry sauce
West VirginiaSweet potatoes
WisconsinCranberry sauce
WyomingGreen bean casserole

If you like this sort of thing, see where the cranberries come from or the rest of my Thanksgiving maps.

Sources: The Daring Kitchen, 2019 (counting more than 50,000 geotagged tweets from 1 November 2019); Fox News, Instacart and Harris Poll 2019; Mental Floss, Instacart sales; AP-NORC 2023; Campbell’s; Wikipedia, Green bean casserole; Philadelphia Inquirer; Who Tweets with Their Location? (study of geotagged tweets).

Random map →

Leave a comment